US Courts Narrow Fraud Liability for Code Exploits
US courts keep separating exploitation of protocol mechanics from fraud, so prosecutors will keep moving toward insider-information and duty-based cases while victims of on-chain manipulation rely on protocol design and civil claims.
weakening · confidence 37 · Emerging (watchlist) · tracking since November 17, 2026 · updated November 22, 2026
Score history
Daily conviction score, 0 to 100. Higher means the thesis is more strongly corroborated.
Now 37 · -2 since Nov 21 · ranged 37 to 39
Showing the last few days. Unlock full score history.
Why the conviction moved
- Nov 18Strengthened +5
Judge Clarke's acquittal turned on the absence of a materially false statement that anyone relied on, not on whether the $25 million profit was fair. That makes reliance-based wire-fraud theories a weak tool against people who exploit protocol mechanics, so future prosecutions are pushed toward cases built on insider information or a breached duty.
- Nov 17Strengthened +6
A federal judge acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers in the $25 million Ethereum MEV-bot case, finding no proven misrepresentation. On the same day, a former Robinhood engineer pleaded guilty to wire fraud for trading Hyperliquid perpetuals on confidential listing data and making $125,523. Exploiting protocol mechanics stayed outside fraud, while the insider-information case succeeded.
Source trail
Supporting · November 18, 2026
Judge acquits Peraire-Bueno brothers in $25 million Ethereum trade, ending the first U.S. criminal case over transaction ordering
Judge Clarke's acquittal turned on the absence of a materially false statement that anyone relied on, not on whether the $25 million profit was fair. That makes reliance-based wire-fraud theories a weak tool against people who exploit protocol mechanics, so future prosecutions are pushed toward cases built on insider information or a breached duty.
CoinDeskSupporting · November 17, 2026
Federal Judge Acquits Peraire-Bueno Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum Bot Case, Finding No Proven Misrepresentation
A federal judge acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers in the $25 million Ethereum MEV-bot case, finding no proven misrepresentation. On the same day, a former Robinhood engineer pleaded guilty to wire fraud for trading Hyperliquid perpetuals on confidential listing data and making $125,523. Exploiting protocol mechanics stayed outside fraud, while the insider-information case succeeded.
BWE News
Unlock full source trail, score history, and daily updates.
Unlock TrendsAffected regions & assets
Townsquare
Argue the thesis in Townsquare.